The First Presbyterian Meeting House in Carlisle

In the 1650s religious dissenters, or non-conformists, were in the ascendancy and during that time dissenting ministers officiated at both St Mary’s and St Cuthbert’s.  However, following the restoration of the monarchy in 1660 things soon changed to the extent that dissenters were effectively denied freedom of worship.  There was a brief respite in 1672 when the King issued an Indulgence, which allowed a level of freedom for dissenters.  Under the Indulgence two licences were granted in Carlisle: one for the house of Barbara Studholme, Independent - equivalent of Congregational - and the other for the house of Edward James, Presbyterian, in the Blackfriars.  This would place Edward James’s house somewhere in the area between Blackfriars Street and West Walls, east to west, and Heads Lane and the Victoria Viaduct, north to south.  However, it is most likely to have been in the corner between Heads Lane and West Walls, in the North West corner of what is now the pay and display car park.

In 1689, following the accession of William and Mary to the throne, the Act of Toleration, which offered an element of freedom of worship to dissenters, was passed into law.  In Carlisle, there was some evidence of dissenting worship, but it was not until 1707 that the protestant dissenters in and around Carlisle registered the new house in the Blackfriars to be erected for religious ends.  Was the meeting house on the same site as Edward James’s house or was it elsewhere?  This is a conundrum that has, unfortunately, not been resolved.

What is known is that within ten years of opening, the chapel had 100 members and that by the 1730s, it was becoming too small to accommodate the worshippers and it was for that reason that the congregation decided to build a new church in Fisher Street.  The meeting house was leased to a Thomas Forster for 40 years and he sub-let it to the overseers of the poor for the parish of St Cuthbert’s Without, i.e. outside the walls.

Finally, in December 1806, the Presbyterian Congregation in Fisher Street advertised for sale, in the Carlisle Journal, premises in the Blackfriars ‘consisting of 5 Dwelling Rooms, a 5 Loom Shop and a small Room fit for holding a Warping Mill’.  The premises were '52 feet and 4 inches in length, 19 feet wide within the Walls, with 9 feet of vacant ground in front'.  Unfortunately, once again no specific location was given.  Assuming that the 1806 property was the same as the 1707 property, albeit significantly altered, it is difficult to understand why a Presbyterian Church would want to own a textile mill, unless, of course it was converted by one of the tenants.

This is only a brief résumé of the detailed research I have carried out in an attempt to identify the exact location of the meeting house, but none of it gets any closer to identifying the exact location of the meeting house.  What it does tell us is that we are now worshipping as little as 100 yards from where Presbyterians in Carlisle first met in the house of Edward James 350 years ago and in the first purpose built Presbyterian Church 35 years later.

To end, one final piece of tantalising information.  In the Fisher Street Session minutes, dated 12 July 1870, a brief history of the church was given, which included the following words: 'Documents exist in connection with this congregation, which show that it existed in the year 1707….  In that year the protestant Presbyterian dissenters in Carlisle purchased a place of worship, a small property, under the West Walls of the City, at a place called the Blackfriars, for this they paid a sum of £50, which was presented to them by a Mr Edgar a merchant in London.' Sadly, the documents no longer survive.


Early Independents or Congregationalists in Carlisle

And did the congregationalists worship at the blackfriars meeting house too?

I provide here a little information about the early Congregationalists or Independents in Carlisle.  For sake of ease I use the word Congregationalist except where quoting from documents.

The second of the two licences for dissenting worship which were granted in Carlisle during the year long Indulgence of 1672 was for the ‘house of Barbara Studholme, Independent’.  Unfortunately, unlike Edward James’s house, no location is given for Barbara’s.  It is known from her will, however, that she owned a house in Castle Street.  Barbara was the widow of Cuthbert Studholme, an ardent supporter of Cromwell.  He was Mayor of Carlisle in the early 1650s, a Justice of the Peace, and one of Cromwell’s Commissioners responsible for the ejection of ‘scandalous ignorant and inefficient’ ministers and schoolmasters.  It is also possible that he was a tacit supporter of the Kaber Rigg plot of 1663, which was a half-hearted and unsuccessful plot, to oust the King, hatched in Westmorland, for which a number of the leaders paid with their lives.

The next identifiable Congregationalist to appear on the scene was Daniel Jackson and we find him initially in the Cockermouth Church Book minutes of 31 July 1692, when he was described as a ‘preacher of the word, who is called to preach the Gospel at Carlisle.’  He was soon in Carlisle, because it is recorded in the minutes of Quarter Sessions of 5 October 1692 that ‘Mr Daniel Jackson, a Dissenting minister hath appointed a house of Mrs Stanwicks at Stanwicks Banks….’  Jackson did not remain long in Carlisle, having been found guilty of marital irregularities.

One of the key Congregationalists in Carlisle, at that time, was a Richard Eaglesfield, who was an Elder at Cockermouth and also related by marriage to the next dissenting minister in Carlisle, John Menzies, both being married to daughters of Henry Fletcher of Tallentire Hall.  From the above it is evident that the Cockermouth church, which was Congregational, was prominent in the planting of Congregationalism in Carlisle.  Menzies is an interesting person in that, whilst he came from Scotland, it is not clear whether he was a Presbyterian or a Congregationalist.  He died in 1703 and was followed, later that year, by Miles Baxter, who was to become the first minister of the Blackfriars meeting house.  Baxter commenced his training for the ministry at Rathmell Academy in North Yorkshire, but completed it at Manchester under James Coningham, who was an avowed Presbyterian.  With Jackson a Congregationalist, Menzies of uncertain denominational allegiance, and Baxter a Presbyterian where does that leave us?  For that we have to turn to the national picture.

Soon after the Act of Toleration was enacted the Presbyterians and Congregationalists decided to co-operate more closely.  The outcome of this closer co-operation was a formal agreement in 1691, which was called the ‘Happy Union.’  In London, however, the term ‘Happy’ was not altogether appropriate because relationships between the two denominations soon broke down.  In the provinces, however, relationships between the two continued, to the extent that some churches of one denomination had a minister of the other or some had members of both denominations.  In this regard, it is noted that when the Blackfriars congregation registered their meeting house in 1707 they described themselves as ‘the protestant dissenters in Carlisle’.  No denomination was identified and, furthermore, the use of the word ‘the’ could suggest that they considered themselves to be the only protestant dissenters in Carlisle at that time.  By 1831, when the land for the Fisher Street Church was purchased they were describing themselves, specifically, as ‘Protestant Dissenters of the Presbyterian denomination.’

The Congregationalists, meanwhile, did not appear as a congregation until c1810 when they took over the Annetwell Street meeting house, which had been occupied under various denominational guises since it opened in 1778.  It was from Annetwell Street that the church moved to Lowther Street, in 1843, where Congregationalists still worship today.

For those that may be interested, a more detailed article can be found in the Transactions of the Cumberland & Westmorland Antiquarian & Archaeological Society, Volume IX, 2009, pages 111-130 or on the Cumbria Past website, under the heading ‘Presbyterians and Independents or Congregationalists in Carlisle 1648-1736.’


Home

ABOUT US

Find Us

Lettings

Home About Us Find Us Lettings